← Gazillion Industries/Reading material

Best doppler plugins

Gazillion Industries ·

Two in the morning, an ambulance takes the corner and the siren sags a couple of semitones as it passes the window. An hour later you try that on a hi-hat, draw a pitch bend on the clip, and get a hi-hat that goes flat in the middle of the speakers and never leaves the middle of the speakers.

The best doppler plugins drive four things from one motion: pitch, from a delay line whose length is changing; level, which falls off with distance; high frequency, which the air absorbs more of the further the sound has to travel; and position across the image. The pitch bend is the famous part and the weakest of the four on its own. The other three are what make an ear put the sound somewhere in the room.

The short version

What it is
a source moving past a listener, not an effect applied to one
Mechanism
a delay line whose length changes; the rate of change is the pitch
The four cues
pitch, level, air absorption, position — all from one path
The tell
pitch crosses unity at the closest point of the pass
Free route
a modulated delay and an auto-panner in the host you already own
For music
a playable bend beats a physics engine you have to draw
SKRUU with PITCH at minus 3.09 semitones and TIME at 19.5 per cent.
PITCH −3.09 ST. About the size of a whole car pass, on one knob.

What a doppler plugin is actually doing

A doppler effect plugin is a delay line with a length that moves. Write into a buffer at a fixed rate and read out of it faster than you wrote, and the audio comes out short and high; read slower and it comes out long and low. Nothing is analyzed and nothing is resynthesized, so the sound keeps its formants, its room and its noise floor. That is the same mechanism as a turntable running fast, described in what is varispeed.

The physics sets the size of the move. Sound travels at about 343 m/s in air at 20 °C. A car coming straight at you at 30 m/s shifts every frequency by a factor of 343 ÷ 313, about 1.6 semitones up. Going away it shifts by 343 ÷ 373, about 1.5 semitones down. Total swing: roughly three semitones, and the rise is slightly larger than the fall. A passenger jet at 250 m/s swings about 22 semitones up and 9 down, which is why the curve is lopsided in a way nobody draws by hand.

The part that surprises people is where the shift goes to zero. Only the component of the speed along the line to your ear counts, so the full shift is reached when the source is far away and pointed straight at you, and it falls to nothing at the moment the source is level with you. The pitch crosses its own unshifted value exactly at the closest point of the pass. How close that pass is decides how fast the bend happens, not how big it gets: a car two meters away snaps through in under a second, a plane 300 meters up takes five.

The whole SKRUU panel in its black finish: PITCH and TIME knobs, the varispeed pitch strip, the two ELASTIC sections, SAMPLING GRADE and the pitch comparator.
The whole thing. Top half is the two rates, bottom half is what happens when you let go.

Why most doppler moves sound wrong

The common failure is a pitch bend with nothing else attached to it. The note sags, the level holds, the top end holds, the image holds, and the ear hears a detuned instrument rather than an object going past. Pitch on its own is the least informative of the four cues. Take it away and leave the other three and you still hear a pass; take the other three away and leave the pitch and you hear a synthesizer.

The second failure is a straight fade for distance. Level from a point source falls 6 dB for every doubling of distance, which means almost all of the change happens in the last few meters and almost none of it happens between 80 and 100. A linear fade spreads the loudness evenly along the path and reads as a slider being moved, because that is what it is.

The third is a dry/wet balance that never moves. Distance is carried more strongly by the ratio of direct sound to reflected sound than by level, which is why a voice at the far end of a hallway is unmistakably far away even at a matched volume. If the send stays fixed while the source travels, the room follows the source around and the depth collapses. That mechanism on its own is how to make music sound like another room.

The fourth is a top end that never changes. Air absorbs high frequencies far more than low ones, a few dB per hundred meters at the top octave and almost nothing at 100 Hz, and the amount swings with humidity. Over a short pass it is subtle. Over a long one it is most of the effect.

What separates a good doppler plugin from a bad one

SKRUU is our varispeed pitch and time stretch plugin, and it covers the pitch-and-speed half of a pass: a sprung knob you throw and release, with sixteen shapes for the way it comes home. There's a demo on the page.

SKRUU with PITCH raised above unity.
Pitched up. The approach half of the curve, before the crossing.

How to test a doppler plugin in ten minutes

You are testing four behaviors, and three of them are visible on a bounced waveform before you hear anything. Do this with the plugin's own demo build, on material you know.

  1. Put a two-second mono noise burst on an empty track at a steady level.
  2. Set the pass so the closest point lands at one second.
  3. Bounce it, then look at the waveform. The level should swell on a curve and dump most of its change in the middle third.
  4. Play the bounce and listen to the top end at the two ends of the file. It should be dull at both and bright in the middle.
  5. Set the source speed to 30 m/s and check the pitch swing. About three semitones, top to bottom, is correct.
  6. Check the pitch at the exact center of the pass. It should sit at the unshifted pitch.
  7. Set the closest approach to 1 m, bounce again, then set it to 50 m and bounce again. The bend should get slower and gentler, not smaller.
  8. Swap the noise for a drum loop and look at the grid. Note whether the hits move, and whether a pitch bypass holds them.
  9. Listen on headphones for the pan, then fold to mono and listen again.
  10. Print the best pass and play it on a phone speaker.

The phone is not an afterthought. A pass built on level and top end survives a phone; a pass built on a wide stereo sweep turns into a mono blip, and most of the ones people upload are the second kind.

SKRUU with TIME at minus 35 per cent and PITCH at unity.
TIME −35%, PITCH at unity. Length moved, pitch held — the switch a pass on a loop needs.

Where it goes in the chain

On the source track, as an insert, before anything that represents the room. The order is the whole argument: distortion, amp tone and any character processing belong to the object and happen first; the pass happens to the finished object; the room happens to the pass. Put a doppler after a reverb and you move the room past the listener along with the source, which is a sound, but not the one anyone asked for.

Feed the reverb from a send that sits after the doppler, post-fader, so the wet level rides the distance curve for free. If the plugin has its own distance reverb, use that instead of the send rather than as well, or you will hear two rooms with different arrival times.

Two practical notes. Delay-line dopplers hold a buffer, so they report latency and can behave oddly when you automate them hard against a moving playhead; print the pass to audio once you like it. And keep them off the master, always. A pass is an event that happens to one thing, and a whole mix cannot move past a listener who is inside it.

Named options, and what each one actually gives you

The category is a small one and the products in it are built for different rooms. What follows is read off each maker's own page.

Waves Doppler. A post-production fixture, and the one whose vocabulary the rest of the field borrowed. Its own page lists control of the track curve, center time, pitch, and start and end points; a display of the path; a reverb tail generator that emulates reflections from the surroundings; an Air Damp control for high-frequency loss with distance; sweeps triggered one-shot or continuously, by hand or by threshold; and 20 presets. It also lists an option to bypass pitch shifting to keep tempo on rhythmic instruments, which is exactly the switch a music session needs.

Sound Particles Doppler. Listed on soundparticles.com at $99 on its own, or $149 bundled with their Air plugin. AAX Native, AUv2 and VST3; macOS 10.9 or higher on Intel or Apple Silicon, and Windows 7 SP1 or higher. The page lists a distance EQ for air damping, units in either meters and km/h or feet and mph, a sync control that pins the peak of the pass to a chosen time for picture, and output formats running from mono microphone patterns through stereo pairs (MS, XY, ORTF, Blumlein, AB) to 5.1, 7.1, a 9.1 Dolby Atmos bed, and Ambisonics up to third order. That list tells you who it is for. If you are working to picture or to an immersive bed, it is the one built for your room.

Cableguys TimeShaper. Listed at €29 on cableguys.com, and it runs inside their ShaperBox 3 host plugin. There is no distance model in it. You draw the position of a virtual playhead as a curve, which gives slow-downs, speed-ups, reverses, scratches and tape stops, locked to beats and bars and triggerable by MIDI or by audio. For a producer who wants the bend on the grid rather than the physics off the grid, drawing the curve is often the faster route. The tape-stop end of that is covered in how to make a tape stop effect.

Auburn Sounds Panagement. A free edition, with the full edition listed at $29 on auburnsounds.com, marked down there from $38.67; VST, AAX, AU and LV2 for Windows, macOS and Linux. It is a binaural distance panner with early and late reflections, width, tilt and an LFO, and the free edition carries everything except the delay and the chip mod. There is no pitch bend in it, so it gives you the distance half without the doppler half — which makes it the cheapest way to learn what distance alone actually sounds like, and a good partner for anything that only bends pitch.

MeldaProduction MFreeFXBundle. Free, 38 effects, with a paid upgrade listed at $56 on meldaproduction.com. MVibrato, MFlanger and MDelay are all in the free set, and a delay with a modulated time is the engine of every doppler there is. Automate the delay time, automate a pan and a low-pass alongside it, and you have built the effect by hand. It takes longer and it teaches you more.

SKRUU with the sampling grade set to LO-FI 1.
SAMPLING GRADE at LO-FI 1. 7.81 kHz rather than 31.25 — a different kind of distance.

Doppler in a beat, not in a film

Post-production wants the pass to be true. Music usually wants it to be legible, and those are different targets. Three semitones is what a car does; three semitones over a bar is almost inaudible in a busy mix. Producers end up exaggerating the bend by a factor of two or three, and that is a legitimate choice as long as you know you are making it rather than trusting a preset labeled for a vehicle.

The moves that survive a mix are small and rhythmic. A single hi-hat thrown past the head at the end of an eight-bar section. An ad-lib that arrives from the left and leaves to the right across two beats. A snare that passes once, at the turnaround, and never again. A riser that gains pitch as it approaches and drops through unity on the downbeat, which is the same crossing the physics gives you and lands harder than any upward sweep because it resolves instead of stopping.

The one that almost always fails is the whole-mix pass. It reads as a mistake, and if it is what you actually want, you want a tape stop or a filter sweep, both of which say the same thing more clearly.

What it costs you

A pass is permanent once it is printed, and it has to be printed, because delay-line automation that is tight at 90 bpm is not tight at 140. Extreme passes lose real top end and never get it back, which is fine going away and wrong coming back if you overdid the damping. Hard stereo passes collapse to a level bump in mono, so anything destined for a phone needs its distance carried by level and tone. And the pitch move drags the timing with it, which means a loop that was on the grid is not on the grid after a pass unless you bypassed the pitch or quantized afterwards. That trade is the same one described in how to change pitch without changing tempo.

Questions people ask

What is the best doppler plugin?

For work to picture, a purpose-built physical simulation with distance EQ, units and a sync control is the right tool, and Waves Doppler and Sound Particles Doppler are both built that way. For music, the best doppler plugin is usually whichever one lets you draw or play the move on the grid, because the target is a musical event rather than a true one. Try the demo builds on a hi-hat before spending anything. The field is small enough that an afternoon covers it.

What is the best doppler effect plugin for music production?

One that can bypass its pitch shifting and still move level, tone and position, so a loop keeps its grid. Failing that, a curve-drawing tool that locks to beats and bars will get you a usable pass faster than a physics engine will, because you are working in the units your session is already in.

Is there a free doppler plugin?

Every piece of it is free, even where the one-window version is not. A modulated delay gives you the pitch, an auto-panner gives you the position, a low-pass gives you the air, and a send gives you the distance. MeldaProduction's free bundle has the delay and the modulation, and Auburn Sounds Panagement has a free edition for the distance and the reflections.

How do you make a doppler effect without a plugin?

Put a short delay on the source, automate its delay time from long to short and back across the pass, and the pitch will rise and fall on its own. Then automate three more things on the same curve: the track fader on an inverse law, a low-pass that opens toward the middle, and the pan from one side to the other. Set the reverb send so it is loudest at the two ends. Print it, because that many automation lanes will not survive a tempo change.

What SKRUU does

SKRUU is a varispeed pitch and time stretch plugin, and it owns the pitch-and-speed half of this move rather than the distance half. PITCH runs from −20% to +10% in 128 states and reads out in semitones as well as speed, so the three semitones a car gives you is a value you can dial rather than guess. TIME runs from −50% to +25% and moves nothing but the length, and PITCH LOCK and TIME LOCK hold one while the other travels — the bypass that keeps a loop on the grid while the rest of the gesture happens.

ELASTIC is the part that makes a pass playable. With it on, the knob is sprung: throw it, let go, and it travels back on its own. RETURN sets how long that takes, free or quantized to the bar. BITE sets how hard it commits. SLOPE is the road home and there are sixteen, including WHIP, HANG, CLIFF and BOUNCE — six smooth, five stepped, five that overshoot and come back, with pitch and time each getting their own. DRAG sets how long a new speed takes to arrive; at the floor it is instant, turned up it is a hand on a platter. The display is a pitch comparator in semitones, so what went in against what came out is a picture rather than a number you have to trust. Pair it with a panner and a distance send and you have the whole pass, built out of parts you can hear separately. SKRUU is $29, Mac and Windows, VST3, AU and standalone.

The whole SKRUU panel in its light finish: PITCH and TIME knobs at unity, the varispeed pitch strip, the two ELASTIC sections, SAMPLING GRADE and the pitch comparator.
Two finishes, black and brushed aluminum. Same machine, different object.

The ambulance did four things at once and never asked you to draw any of them. Get the other three moving and the hi-hat will leave the middle of the speakers.

SKRUU — varispeed pitch and time stretch for Mac and Windows. Pitch and time move independently, with sixteen elastic return shapes.

Hear it

Keep reading

Gazillion Industries LLC · reading material